Minimalist Web Design: How Minimal is Too Minimal?

Dec 5 2011 by Delwin Campbell | 10 Comments

Minimalist Web Design: How Minimal is Too Minimal?

Minimalism, interestingly enough, is usually born out of excess. In all arts, in all ways of life, we start out by taking and adding whatever we can.

When we start to realize that more is not necessarily better, and that we can get by with less stuff, we try to simplify by removing unnecessary elements so we can focus on what’s truly important.

What is Minimalism?

Minimalism, in its purest form, is the reduction of something to its bare essentials.

Think of a car. It only needs a few critical components — engine, wheels, gas, and so on — for it to run. As long as it has these parts, you can take out many non-essential elements such as its audio system, heated leather seats and cup holders, and the car will still get you to where you’re going.

In web design, minimalism translates to producing a site from the basics. Instead of including everything but the kitchen sink and then paring it down to only the necessary features, a better approach would be to start with a blank slate and only include the essentials.

Minimalism is an exercise in restraint, with the eventual goal being a design that helps the user focus and accomplish their tasks as quickly as possible.

When designing minimalist websites, you should keep three things in mind:

  • Subject: What’s the most important thing on the web page? Is it effectively keeping the user engaged and focused?
  • Usability: What things burden the user experience? What missing elements can enhance user-friendliness?
  • Balance: Does the web page have the appropriate visual hierarchy and do components have appropriate visual weights?

These three elements are actually the most important elements in all styles of web design, but whereas other visual styles may beg for additional aesthetic layers, minimalism does not.

Why Use Minimalism?

This minimalist thinking is the basis of modern web design — we begin with content, perhaps a brand, but nothing else. By adding in only what’s necessary, we create a website that caters specifically and solely to its mission.

There are many benefits to designing a minimalist website.

First is the obvious: Minimalist web designs usually end up with fewer code and site assets. A minimalist site will often have fewer CSS rules, HTML elements, images, JavaScript, and so on. This ultimately means increased front-end web performance and, in turn, enhanced usability and a better user experience.

This doesn’t mean the design stage is any easier — minimalism takes just as much thought, planning and production as any other type of website. And perhaps even more, if my theory about our innate desire for "more stuff" is correct.

Zen Habits’s archive page shows how easy it can be to build a minimalist website once the concept is there.

It’s also harder to mess up minimalism, in my opinion. By proactively leaving out superfluous elements, your design becomes more open and free. When there’s less to see, there will be fewer distractions. As long as you give ample consideration to balance, typography and white space, your design will look pretty good. This is much easier than wrangling with a PSD template with dozens of layers.

And for those who have little artistic skill or proficiency in Photoshop, minimalism is a perfect way to create a site using only a strong understanding of typography, white space, and balance.

While not the most minimalist of examples in this article, Julien LavallĂ©e’s site (featured below) demonstrates how interesting and visually appealing simple websites can be.

However, the most important reason to design minimally is that, without extraneous design elements, the site’s content is emphasized. By adding more white space, the various sections of a website are given breathing room.

On Daniel Gray’s site, notice how enough white space is given around each content section so that readers can quickly focus on the content without being distracted by much else.

The one problem with the site is that the reader’s eye focuses on the content in an odd order. My eyes go from the navigation bar, to the image of the unicorn, then to "Daniel Gray", and then finally to the "Hello, I’m a designer and writer based in York." tagline. But because there aren’t a whole lot of visual elements to distract the reader, this order doesn’t matter so much. In a visually busier site, some of this content would get lost, but here, although I see things in a different order than what’s probably optimal, I still consider each content element in turn.

Don’t Sacrifice Usability for Minimalism

As we’ve all heard by now, "content is king", and although there are some that might disagree with that, there are very few who would say content is not important at all. Every line of code you write is to serve the page’s content in some way.

Just as important as content is how accessible that content is — without adequate consideration of usability, content can be difficult to find and read.

Now that we have new web standards and technologies like CSS3 and HTML5 at our disposal, we must deeply consider what is necessary so that we avoid the overuse of these things. (I wrote something about this before.)

My suspicion is that as web technology grows tantalizingly better and more complex, minimalists are going to have a harder time paring down their designs to the essentials, especially as certain superfluous design patterns have become almost expected, like using CSS transitions to make links hover a little softer.

But always in the back of your mind should be considerations of usability. Chances are — unless you’re a big, established and well-recognized company like Apple, Starbucks or Nike — you should probably include the name of your company with your logo. And don’t think you can reduce your navigation menu to a set of enigmatic icons; even if it doesn’t confuse most readers, it will confuse some.

Don’t Worry, You Can Still Be Pretty

Designing minimally doesn’t always have to mean a reduction to the barest essentials. To the contrary, many minimalist sites include subtle design elements that manifest themselves beautifully and more remarkably because of fewer competing, distractive elements.

Chance Graham’s site, for example, has great use of color, iconography and subtle visual effects (like the box shadow on the navigation items at the top-left of the web page layout) that add enough nuances to intrigue the user without them being a disturbance.

Are You Designing Minimally for a Good Reason?

Minimalism on the Web could be thought of not as an aesthetic, but as the lack of one. If you "go minimal" just for its looks without understanding the purpose of minimalism, you will be lost, and your designs will turn out less than stellar.

Just as any other art genre or design style, minimalism must be well understood in order to be well executed — don’t let simple-looking web designs fool you; there is more going on with them than what can be seen on the surface.

In addition, minimalism shouldn’t be arbitrarily confusing or enigmatic. Many people see minimalist websites as a way to make their brand seem more mysterious, but this isn’t the goal, and there are much more effective ways to build a mythos around your brand than designing it inappropriately.

When any design is confusing, or enigmatic in its structure, or uncomfortable in its balance, it throws the viewer off. The last thing you want is a confused user, unable to find what they’re looking for.

In general, you should avoid ambiguity and confusion when designing in any style. Minimalism is no exception. In fact, minimalism is the design style where ambiguity must be avoided like the plague, and usability embraced, analyzed and perfected to the point where no user could possibly be confused in any instance when visiting your site.

Most importantly, make sure you clearly understand the goal of minimalist design before you plunge right in. Without proper direction, your creations could end up something like the piece below, which is great for many things except for conveying information in a clear and effective way.

James Turrell’s Space That Sees demonstrates the difference between minimalist art and minimalist design.

The goal that you should strive for, when employing minimalism in your designs, is to enhance readability, improve navigation and usability, and, as always, create the most pleasant user experience possible.

Is Your Design Too Minimal?

Your design might be too minimal if:

  • You’re using minimalism for the wrong reason
  • If you’re sacrificing usability in any way

These problems are easy to fix as long as you understand the goal of visual design in general: To clearly and effectively convey information. Constantly consider how your design decisions affect your users.

At the core of every design is minimalist thinking: the idea that few things are actually necessary and critical.

Related Content

About the Author

Delwin Campbell is a web developer (among other things) at No Enemies, based in Austin, Texas. He is a crazy person with too many hobbies; right now he’s learning Swedish! Check out his personal site.

10 Comments

Marco

December 5th, 2011

Hello, interesting approach Delwin, even though I don’t agree when you say “a better approach would be to start with a blank slate and only include the essentials”. In web design is much easier to remove something after you’ve added it if the aim is Minimalism, also because ( luckily) in web design don’t exist changes that are absolutely destructive.

Dumitru Brinzan

December 5th, 2011

I have been designing mostly minimalist-style for the past 3 years and I am perfectly happy with it.

If you have great content, there is no need to clutter it with heavy graphics and unnecessary elements.

Designerfied

December 5th, 2011

Great read! I have always liked a clean minimal design better than a site that’s crammed with graphics.

Jonathan Ogden

December 5th, 2011

Great article Delwin! I agree with many of your points especially about minimalism improving usability. I’ve seen quite a few websites that have a minimal design but really poor layout and navigation and so the usability is quite poor! Quite a few of these have been portfolio type sites for really top quality graphic designs that are great at print design but maybe don’t fully understand the usability aspects of web design and so just bring their minimal style straight over into the web.

I don’t really think there is a ‘too minimal’ and some designs can be really striking if they’re almost blank! I tend to do things the other way around than what you mentioned, starting with a minimal design and then asking “should I add more textures / colours / images / visual elements” and “would it add to or detract from the experience if I added these things”?

Kuzey Guney

December 5th, 2011

Thank you very nice ;)

Andy Blue Monkey

December 5th, 2011

There is a great quote i got from ‘The Four Hour Work Week’

Perfection is not when there is nothing more to add, but when there is nothing more to take away…

I cant remember who said it though!

Goob

December 5th, 2011

What’s too minimal? The new google docs. The new gmail. The new google analytics. The new google webmaster tools. And I’m guessing just about every other google owned property in recent weeks. I’m not sure if their only designer (I’m sure they only have one) just picked up a copy of Simple and Usable and laid down a mandate to remove ALL colour and supporting lines in a naive effort to be more usable. But in my opinion they’ve failed miserably. The old google was good because it was usable. The new google 2.1 “less is more” or should I say “nothing is more” style is nothing more than latching on to the wrong end a fad. Minimalism has its place when done right. Google does it wrong. IMHO.

Jared

December 12th, 2011

I like clean sites, but to minimal seems generic. Balance is key.

Greeny

December 12th, 2011

Very Useful Info !!!!

Minimal Design with multiple page setup websites Always rocks!!!

Nigel T Packer

December 13th, 2011

Delwin,

You say in your article to start with a blank sheet. This for us is the starting point of all projects. The next stage and subsequent steps in the process are defined by the needs and requirements of the user. Once those have been satisfied then the imagery/visual design contributes to the positioning and perception development of the brand. By being minimalist you run the risk of not answering users’ questions and ultimately failing promise fulfilment. These are all issues that a website needs to address.

Kind regards

Nigel T Packer

Leave a Comment

Subscribe to the comments on this article.